| Platinum | Crumbl |
| Gold | Melissa's Simply Sweet |
| Silver | Westhampton Pastry Shop |
| Bronze | River City Chocolate |
| Top Pick | Bub's and Gracies Ice Cream and Cookies |
| Top Pick | Dunkin' |
| Top Pick | Happybottoms Cheesecakes |
| Top Pick | Montana Gold Bread Co |
| Top Pick | Red Eye Cookie Company |
| Top Pick | Sally Bell's Kitchen |