| Platinum | Country Style Donuts |
| Gold | Donuts Company |
| Silver | Sugar Shack Donuts |
| Bronze | MRS. Yoder's |
| Top Pick | Duck Donuts |
| Top Pick | Dunkin' |
| Top Pick | Oh! Mochi Richmond |
| Top Pick | Sally Bell's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | The Treat Shop RVA |
| Top Pick | Westhampton Pastry Shop |