| Platinum | Croaker's Spot |
| Gold | The Boathouse at Rocketts Landing |
| Silver | The Hardshell Downtown |
| Bronze | Riptides Seafood Restaurant |
| Top Pick | East Coast Provisions |
| Top Pick | Island Shrimp Co. |
| Top Pick | Latitude Seafood Co. Richmond |
| Top Pick | Rappahannock Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Saltbox Oyster Co |