| Platinum | Anna's Pizza Hull Street |
| Gold | Dante's of Ironbridge |
| Silver | Colonial Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Mama Cucina |
| Top Pick | Anna's Pizza Mechanicsville |
| Top Pick | Bella Luna |
| Top Pick | Carrabba's Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Casa Italiana |
| Top Pick | Romas |
| Top Pick | The Grapevine Greek & Italian Restaurant |
| Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |